.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

shrinkykitten

"...another reason I'm intrigued with the hanged of Salem, especially the women, is that a number of them aroused suspicion in the first place because they were financially independent, or sharp-tongued, or kept to themselves. In other words, they were killed off for the same sort of life I live right now but with longer skirts and fewer cable channels." Sarah Vowell, The partly cloudy patriot.

12.13.2005

Insensitive, unintentionally

It is hard for me to be very sensitive to people who don't celebrate christmas and who push to say "happy holidays" rather than "merry christmas" or push for non-christmas iconography, etc. One might be surprised at this given that I was raised in such a strictly atheistic household and given that even as a kid I protested against things that were too religious (like refusing to be a girl scout due to needing to pledge to god, refusing to say the pledge of allegiance, and insisting that certain songs be removed from my elementary school's christmas pageant).

But, I think what is interesting is that my family celebrated christmas with huge fervor. Our christmas traditions and celebrations were an extremely important family ritual, and were completed dissociated from any religious meaning. Thus, I have come to see christmas as a cultural holiday, not a religious or even quasi-religious one. I also -- to my knowledge -- didn't know a single person who *didn't* celebrate christmas while I was growing up (even though it was a *very* diverse area). In our area of California, there were few Jewish people, so although I know about the Jewish religion (and as a kid, I was actually convinced my family was really Jewish), I never really understood that some/many Jewish people don't celebrate christmas. It actually wasn't until I moved to the city where I live now, where there are many Jewish people and people of other religions who don't celebrate, that I really grokked that. But still, my perception of christmas as more akin to Thanksgiving or Halloween or New Years persists.

This is odd to me because you would think I'd really be on the "Holiday" rather than "Christmas" bandwagon, but I'm not totally. I mean, I get it intellectually that people who don't celebrate christmas feel excluded and marginalized, and I don't think that is good at all. But at the same time, I think -- "Christmas is fun! Celebrate it too!" I mean, who wouldn't want a sparkly metallic tree with pink pom-pom sparkly ornaments, and eggnog (soynog), and christmas stockings, and christmas carols (especially French ones!), and Santa, and christmas eve appetizer-focused dinners (that's our family tradition), and reindeers, etc., etc. I feel badly that I am so insensitive.

2 Comments:

At 4:18 PM, Blogger sheepish said...

Christmassy shrinky: I know what you mean. I mean, I completely love the secular and commercial aspects of Christmas, and I celebrate it religiously too.

You were convinced your family was Jewish? I think that needs explaining.

 
At 11:06 PM, Blogger wolfa said...

Ah, yes, another person who wasn't raised in some non-Christian religion telling people who were that Christmas is secular! Get with it!

Happy Holidays is nice and general -- it includes the day off from work, New Years, any other celebrations which might fall in the midwinter. We don't say Happy New Year for an entire month, and there's no need to do the same for Christmas. Say Merry Christmas on Dec 24 and 25, fine, but for the rest of the season? What is so wrong with Happy Holidays unless you actually know the other person is Christian?

I dislike "Holiday Trees" -- they're Christmas trees, and they are indeed very pretty, and I like to see them. Lights, too. I love looking at it all. Just don't tell me they're neutral on religion. See all those people you now know who are Jewish and Muslim and whatever who don't believe that Christmas is their secular holiday with those secular trees? It's not up to you to tell tehm otherwise. Maybe in the future N. America will do what other countries have done and Christmas will become secular there. But we're not there now, and it's remarkably obnoxious to be told which other traditions should be yours.

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home